A Review of Energy & Natural Resources Law Issues at the 2023 UND Law Review Symposium
Updated: Nov 15, 2023
The 2023 University of North Dakota (UND) Law Review's symposium was held on Thursday, March 23, 2023, in Bismarck, North Dakota. The presentations at the symposium examined the role of law and regulation governing the development of carbon, capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS), including carbon dioxide (CO2) transportation infrastructure; a review of oil and gas royalties and pooling issues; and the status of the Missouri river and lake Sakakawea mineral issues.
My presentation comprised a review of the emerging legal and regulatory developments in the commercialization and use of underground pore spaces for energy decarbonization operations. It outlined the underlying property law principles governing the use of such subsurface areas for CCUS operations and options for developing an integrated approach to commercializing CO2.
Globally, there is growing interest in how such CO2 can be captured from various industrial and energy production sources and permanently stored or used in enhanced oil recovery operations, food processing, raw material for producing synthetic fuels and chemicals, building materials, etc. The right to use and possess the subsurface pore spaces largely depend on whether such formations or voids are within the land(s) owned by private individuals such as a farmer or owned by the federal government or other public agencies. I highlighted the relevant legal framework and provisions in jurisdictions like Alberta, Canada, and Norway with regard to developing CCUS projects. Then discussed some of the relevant judicial decisions in the US from Texas and North Dakota regarding the ownership and rights to use underground pore spaces between a typical landowner and owner of a mineral estate. The North Dakota Supreme Court recently addressed this issue in the case of Northwest Landowners Association v. State 2022 ND 150, 978 N.W.2d 679.
Other papers and presentations from the symposium are available at the 2023 North Dakota Law Review Energy Law Symposium. Speakers at the symposium include Kevin Connors (UND's Energy and Environmental Research Center), James Curry, Attorney, Babst Colland Attorneys at Law, Juan Palma, Senior Policy Advisor to the U.S. Bureau of Land Management, Craig Smith, Attorney, Crowley Fleck PLLP, Joshua Swanson, Attorney, Vogel Law Firm, Paul Forster, Attorney, Crowley Fleck PLLP.
See the Spring 2023 issue of the Gavel Magazine (a publication of the State Bar Association of North Dakota) for a brief summary of presentations at the symposium.
Symposium materials, slides, and information are available here
Thinking about following curiosity through everyday information, I find the smaller practical questions more interesting than a quick conclusion. A clear question can turn a casual interest into something easier to explore. It is the kind of question I would keep in mind when thinking about 2welve and 2welve learning ideas. I would rather explore one useful example carefully than pretend that the whole subject is already clear. How do you decide which detail deserves a closer look before moving on?
I keep coming back to the everyday side of exploring scientific questions through clear examples, where a simple detail can lead to a wider question. A useful explanation shows how an observation connects with the question being investigated. That practical perspective helps me frame science learning ideas as a theme for Stemcellwanglab. It leaves me curious about the steps between understanding an idea and putting it into practice. What simple comparison would help someone understand why a result matters?
I like thinking about communicating ideas to the right audience through small observations rather than trying to reach a conclusion immediately. A clear explanation of a practical benefit can be more useful than a string of enthusiastic claims. I would connect Seamonstermarketing with digital marketing ideas through an ordinary example rather than a broad claim. That is the part I would keep thinking about after moving on to something else. What would make a short message feel relevant rather than intrusive?
What interests me about building confidence through manageable learning goals is how a broad idea becomes part of an ordinary day. A clear first step can make a difficult subject feel more approachable. It is the kind of question I would keep in mind when thinking about Practicalresources and practical learning skills. That is the part I would keep thinking about after moving on to something else. How do you decide what to practise when a topic initially seems too broad?
I like thinking about following curiosity through everyday information through small observations rather than trying to reach a conclusion immediately. A clear question can turn a casual interest into something easier to explore. It is the kind of question I would keep in mind when thinking about Neshawonderland and Neshawonderland learning ideas. I am still thinking through the practical side, because the context can change what seems useful. How do you decide which detail deserves a closer look before moving on?